The Old Grey Thinker

Your tools sound very sure of themselves. That is not the same as being right.

A short, wry field guide to staying sharp around phones, satnavs and AI, with a companion that has read every page and helps you check what your devices tell you.

By The Old Grey Thinker · 11 modules · 1 resource · 1 person has it

The Instruments Lie Sometimes

The tool being wrong is rarely the problem.

Your phone remembers for you. The satnav notices for you. Something on the screen now answers in full, well-punctuated sentences, and sounds exactly as sure when it is wrong as when it is right.

That last part is the trouble. A fogged radar at least has the decency to look like static. A confidently wrong answer looks like an answer.

I spent a career at sea reading instruments that occasionally lied to me, in specific, learnable ways, when believing the lie could cost a good deal more than an afternoon. This short book is what that taught me, applied to a house with rather more instruments in it than any bridge I ever stood on.

What this is

An opening story about six hours of fog with no radar. Seven short chapters, each one habit. An afterword on the machines I still do not trust, among them a smart doorbell, a self-checkout and a very polite voice assistant that once set a timer for twelve months. And a one-page list of things to try this month. It is short enough to read in an evening, though it is not meant to be rushed.

The seven habits

  1. Always keep a second source.
  2. Know the exact conditions in which it lies to you.
  3. Do the sum yourself, at least once, before you automate it.
  4. Keep the skill even after you have stopped needing it daily.
  5. Notice when the looking becomes optional, and refuse it.
  6. Remember the tool being wrong was never the real risk.
  7. Practise going without it before the day you have to.

They are not rules to follow with rigour. They are seven things a younger version of me would have liked to hear before he handed anything, however capable, the job of deciding on his behalf.

And a companion that has read every page

Bring it something a tool has just told you: a route, a figure, a warning, an answer from an AI. It will help you run a second-source check. What is riding on it, what could confirm it that does not depend on the first source, and where that kind of tool tends to go wrong.

Or open any chapter and talk it through. It will put the end-of-chapter question to you one at a time, help you choose the one tool to go without this month, and keep its answers short.

It is an AI, and says so. It can be wrong, which rather proves the point of the book.

What this is not

It is not a technology course and it will not fix your phone. It will never ask for a password, a code or a card number. It is not medical, legal or financial advice. And it is not one of those books that ends with you throwing your devices in the harbour and taking up whittling. I use all of it, daily, without complaint.

Read it your way

Read it in whatever order gets you through it. Put the kettle on first, though. That part is not negotiable.

What's inside

1Start here2 modules
  1. 1A Word Before We Start
  2. 2Opening: Six Hours, No Radar
2The seven things7 modules
  1. 1Chapter One: Always Keep a Second Source
  2. 2Chapter Two: Know the Exact Conditions in Which It Lies to You
  3. 3Chapter Three: Do the Sum Yourself, at Least Once, Before You Automate It
  4. 4Chapter Four: Keep the Skill Even After You've Stopped Needing It Daily
  5. 5Chapter Five: Notice When the Looking Becomes Optional, and Refuse It
  6. 6Chapter Six: The Tool Being Wrong Was Never the Real Risk
  7. 7Chapter Seven: Practice Going Without It Before the Day You Have To
3To finish2 modules
  1. 1Closing: The Whole Job
  2. 2A Few Machines I Still Don't Trust, and Why

Plus 1 file, all inside the product.

What you can ask

  • A tool just told me something and I am not sure I believe it. Help me check it.
  • Take me through Chapter One and put the question at the end to me.
  • Help me work out the exact conditions in which my phone, satnav or AI gets things wrong.
  • Walk me through going without one tool this month, so I know what I would have left.
The Old Grey Thinker

About The Old Grey Thinker

Retired Master Mariner, formerly of the bridge, now writing The Old Grey Thinker: dry, honest notes on retirement, ageing and the quiet absurdities of modern life. Tea mandatory.

Questions

Who is this for?

Anyone who uses a phone, a satnav or an AI every day and has noticed that they sound very certain. You do not need to be technical, and you do not need to be retired, though it helps.

Is it against technology?

No. The book says so early and means it. It is about using a tool well without handing it the job.

What does the companion actually do?

It has read every page. Tell it what a tool told you and it helps you check it. Or open a chapter and it talks it through, asks the end-of-chapter question, and guides you through the going-without exercise. It keeps its answers short and ends with a question.

Can the companion be wrong?

Yes. It is an AI, and it will say so. That is rather the point of the book, so it will also tell you how to check what it says.

Will it ask for my passwords?

Never. It will tell you not to share a password, a one-time code or a card number with anyone, including it.

How long does it take?

It is short enough to read in an evening if you must. Most readers will take a chapter at a time.

Do I need to be good with computers?

No. You read in your browser on a phone, tablet or computer, and the chat works like a text message.

Can I get a refund?

All sales are final. This is a digital product, so once you have access the sale cannot be reversed. Please read this page before buying. If you have a genuine access problem, email the support address on your receipt.

Get The Instruments Lie Sometimes

$19 one time. Ready to chat the moment you sign up.

Start reading

The Old Grey Thinker

Written by The Old Grey Thinker, for anyone whose devices have started doing the noticing.