The Old Grey Thinker
← The Old Grey Thinker

At the Eleventh Hour I Noticed I'd Stopped Asking Anyone's Opinion but My Own

The Old Grey Thinker2 min read

At eleven, I turn the radio down and leave my hand on the knob. There is a red poppy beside the newspaper, and a mug of tea which can wait a couple of minutes without suffering any great injustice.

I stand rather than sit — an old habit.

When the silence ends, I reach for the radio and notice something uncomfortable. Most mornings, I have already decided what I think before anybody else has finished speaking. The radio supplies the subject. I supply the judgement. We have developed a conversation in which only one participant can be interrupted.

Working life made that harder. Retirement removes much of that daily resistance. I can choose what to read, stop listening when I'm irritated, and carry an opinion from breakfast to bedtime without letting anything inconvenient near it.

Our generation was taught to make our minds up. Nobody explained that a made-up mind needs occasional maintenance, particularly when its owner is spending more time alone with it. We complain about people living in bubbles while polishing our own from the inside with a perfectly serviceable newspaper.

I don't mean I have stopped caring what anybody thinks. No, that's generous. I sometimes care intensely, provided they think something close enough to my view that I can describe them as sensible.

My open mind has developed visiting hours and a fairly strict dress code.

That is funny until I hear myself answering a person who hasn't actually said what I assume they are about to say. The quiet humiliation is discovering that experience can become a means of avoiding attention. Having seen plenty doesn't mean I have seen this person, in this moment, with this difficulty.

I miss the friction of working with other people more than I expected. But another voice could interrupt the certainty I was building. A raised eyebrow sometimes saved a considerable amount of unnecessary speech. Now the eyebrow has to be mine. It isn't always reliable.

There is a difference between choosing quiet and choosing a life in which nothing can contradict you. I like the first. I seem occasionally to have drifted into the second, with the radio murmuring reassuringly in the corner until it says something I dislike. Then I turn it down and call that peace.

I don't need to agree with every unfamiliar view. But an answer is more useful when it follows an actual question rather than the imaginary one I've been preparing for. Listening isn't surrendering my experience — it is letting somebody else's experience stand beside it without immediately ordering it out of the room.

So I try to leave a small gap between what I think and what I say. Just enough room for somebody else's version of events to get in.

I turn the radio back up. A voice resumes, and for once I let the sentence finish before deciding what it means. Retirement can make space for curiosity as well as certainty, though curiosity takes rather more effort than I had budgeted for.

I'm trying to distinguish having an opinion from protecting it against all visitors. If your own mind has got more certain as the days get quieter: who was the last person you actually allowed to change your mind, rather than merely finish their sentence?

Visit my Eden store: https://dub.sh/eden-store-email

Get The Old Grey Thinker in your inbox

Retirement, ageing, and becoming invisible, without the fluff. Honest guides and practical tools from a former master mariner who’s working out the next chapter in public. Tea mandatory.

Keep reading