The Old Grey Thinker
← The Old Grey Thinker

Nobody Warns You Which Friendships End at Sixty-Five

The Old Grey ThinkerPaid19 min read

A black and white woodcut engraving in the style of an old fashioned woodblock print, with dense parallel hatching lines, fine stippled detail, and stark high contrast. No colour, no grey tones beyond the hatching itself. Two men sit facing each other across a small cafe table in the foreground, shown from the side, both in their sixties, one wearing a coat, both leaning slightly forward in the posture of two people deep in familiar agreement. A single phone lies face up on the table between them, dark, its screen blank and empty. Behind and above them, the entire background is a vast swirling vortex of concentric engraved lines spiralling inward and upward like a black hole, sucking everything toward its empty dark centre, the lines growing tighter and finer as they near the void. Scattered through the swirling lines are drifting debris: a ship's form dissolving into fragments, a few loose sheets of paper, an empty chair, all being pulled away and upward into the dark. The two men remain solid and anchored at the table, unbothered, tiny against the enormous vortex. Harsh directional lighting from above and to the left, deep black shadows, thin white highlights. Grim, austere, European folk-art engraving feel, mid-twentieth century. Landscape composition, wide.

There is a specific kind of friendship that only exists because you both had the same complaint.

I had one for eleven years with a man I’ll call Ray. We met at a conference in Aberdeen and discovered within four minutes that we both hated the same procurement process, the same regulatory body and the same three people.

Four minutes is not long. I’ve spent longer than that choosing a sandwich. But in those four minutes we established that we were the same sort of man, that we had noticed the same failures, and that neither of us was going to be asked to justify any of it. I remember walking out of that room feeling that I had been understood, which is a feeling I’d like to have been sharper about at the time, because what had actually happened was that I had been agreed with.

We were genuinely good friends. I want that on the record, and I want it on the record early, because there is a version of this piece that reads as a man settling scores four months after a funeral. That isn’t it. We had dinner every time I was in the city. We had a standing arrangement that outlasted two of my jobs and one of his. He came to a thing at my house in 2014 that he had no reason to attend. People knew his name. If you’d asked me at any point between 2009 and 2019 to name my closest professional friendship, I’d have said Ray, and I’d have meant it, and I’d have been telling you the truth.

We had a shared language made almost entirely of grievances.

That is the thing worth looking at now, though I couldn’t see it at the time. We didn’t have a language in the sense of two men who had known each other long enough to skip the small talk. We had a vocabulary, and every word in it referred to something we both disliked. I could say six letters of an acronym down a phone line and Ray would know which meeting I meant, which department I meant, which of the three of us was in the room. That shorthand took years to build. It was genuinely impressive. It was also the whole of the house, and I don’t think either of us ever went upstairs.

Ray rang me four months after I retired. And about ten minutes in, the conversation did something I wasn’t ready for.

He started telling me about a problem at work. A real one, by the sound of it, something that had come back after being settled, which is the worst kind, and which the two of us had spent a decade and a half being right about. And I realised, somewhere around the fifth minute, that I had no stake in it. None.

That’s the point I keep coming back to, and it isn’t the fact that he rang me. He rang me. What undid me was the discovery that the thing he was telling me about no longer existed for me at all. The people in it were people I used to know. The process was a process I used to beat. I could have made the noises. I knew exactly which noises to make. He wasn’t asking my opinion and I wasn’t offering one. It was just a man telling someone who used to care.

We both heard it happen. I think that’s the part I’d have to be honest about if you asked me what the worst half-hour of my retirement was. Not the silence, and not the realisation. The fact that we both heard it, and neither of us said anything, and we kept going for another fifteen minutes because there were fifteen minutes available.

We got to twenty minutes, said the usual things, and neither of us has rung the other since.

Nobody warns you that the first friendships to go are the ones built on shared complaint. Not the ones you argued with. The ones you agreed with.

The rest of this issue is for paid subscribers.

Become a paid subscriber

$50.00/yr

Already a paid subscriber? Read it in Eden

Or get the free issues by email.

Keep reading